The other day, I was introduced to something new by my aunt (who happens to have a peanut intolerance): SunButter. It's basically like peanut butter, except that it's made out of sunflower seeds. And get this: it actually tastes almost exactly like peanut butter. I have tried a small variety of nut butters, like almond and hazelnut, and while I do think they taste great, I wouldn't consider any of them an alternative for peanut butter. I would never make an almond butter and jelly sandwich.
But SunButter, I would.
Oh, and it's also (gasp!) good for you! Per the SunButter website, it has less saturated fat than peanut butter, double the fiber, naturally higher in Vitamin E, and has NO trans fats.
So naturally, almost as soon as I tried it my first thought was that I HAVE to make peanut butter cookies (there goes the healthy part. Hah). Except with SunButter. So, peanut butterless cookies.
I was really excited, because 1) due to my husband's allergies, I hadn't made/eaten peanut butter cookies in forever, which made me want them even more, 2 )my husband is not a real big fan of sweets, but he used to love peanut butter cookies (I guess he didn't used to be allergic to peanuts when he was young.. it was an acquired allergy. I think. I don't know), and 3) my son can enjoy them with us, as it contains absolutely no peanuts or nuts, and isn't even manufactured in a place that contains peanuts or nuts.
At first I was just going to use a regular peanut butter cookie recipe, and just substitute the SunButter like for like. However, I decided to first do a little research to see if that was recommended.
After consulting Head Baker Google, I decided I was glad that I looked, because numerous comments pointed out that sometimes when baking with SunButter your product will turn a fungus-y green. I didn't really want to make fugus cookies, so following a suggestion on a review I headed over to the SunButter webite. Under their recipe tab, they have a little tip telling you to cut back on your baking soda and baking powder so your food doesn't turn green. Oh and the green stuff isn't fungus after all, just a chemical reaction, something to do with the chlorophyll in the sunflower seeds. So it won't hurt you if you do eat it. But good luck trying to get anyone to eat green peanut butter(less) cookies.
They also had a whole bunch of recipes that have already been modified so no reaction resembling a fungus will occur. I decided to use this basic Sunbutter Cookie recipe, because it was the one that most resembled a normal peanut butter cookie recipe. Plus, I happened to have everything on hand, so no grocery store run.. yay!
The finished product:
They turned out amazing, if I do say so myself. To me, they taste identical to regular peanut butter cookies (not like I sampled one from every batch to make sure...).
I'm impatient, so I took them down to my husband's work so he could try them. He was a little hesitant because they looked and smelled so much like peanut butter cookies. But once he ate one, and realized that his mouth and throat wasn't itching and closing up, he loved them. Then proceeded to eat more, and tell me it's my fault if he gets fat, because he's never eaten this many cookies (of course I took that as a compliment). No one else could even tell it wasn't peanut butter, and only believed it wasn't because my husband was eating them.
Oh, and if you wondering, the cool design was made from a potato smasher. It was much easier and faster to use than a fork, and I thought it made the cookies look prettier.